Israeli impunity is driven partly by undisciplined IDF revenge

 
From: "Terry Lodge tjlodge50@PROTECTED [Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition]" <peacelist@PROTECTED>
In-Reply-To: (no subject)
Date: February 25th 2024
The below opinion column is from Haaretz, which is Israel's most politically liberal mainstream paper. Take 5 minutes to absorb the grave import: the army occupying Gaza is looting and murdering with no accountability. Unprecedented loosely-expressed social media opinions and acts by IDF soldiers from the grunt level on up, including demands to destroy Lebanon and the West Bank and not to stop at crushing of Gaza, are increasingly being vocalized. There seems to be very poor control of the public messages and public perceptions of the fighting troops by the command structure. This surely lends some insight into the countless crass and endlessly cruel means of killing and punishing Gazans that are being reported.

The command levels of IDF are either in sympathy with the pathological lawlessness, or feel they cannot curb it at the risk of their careers and influence. Or maybe they realize it strengthens Netanyahu's and the uber-right's political grasp of Israel and also subscribe to the testosterone-drenched, over-the-top aspirations of regional conquest.

Even though Netanyahu draws 15% approval ratings, his only serious political challengers come from even further to the right, if that can be imagined. He has let the IDF rape and pillage at will for his own political survival. That's why the Rafah carnage will roll ahead, full scale, in a couple of weeks. The interesting question will be, as Israel gives the finger to the planet, whether they will proceed northward to invade Lebanon and also to direct much greater military violence at Palestinians in the West Bank. And touch off a massive regional war.

Presently, Israel has enough armaments for 19 weeks more of fighting and is utterly dependent on the $14 Bn bill pending in Congress. One way or another, the Rethugs will approve that spending, which with Biden's milquetoast indifference will make it possible for Israel to push on to the regional war they're so incredibly hungry to have. It'll go down largely because discipline in the military has collapsed, the low-echelon troops are more than willing to keep up the genocide, and that IDF or civilian government leaders with a shred of sanity -- not that there appear to be many or any in Israel at the moment -- are going to keep their heads down. This is known as slumping toward Armageddon.

    Here's the Haaretz editorial:

Opinion |

The Israeli Army Must Act Before Some of Its Soldiers Turn Into Lawless Gangs

Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Yagil Levy
Jan 22, 2024

It is possible to consider the videos of soldiers shown at The Hague as anecdotal and accuse the right wing of distributing them. But the truth is that it marks a precedent: soldiers exploiting social media to challenge the senior command and even the political leadership, which the extreme right believes is too restrained.

The challenge is direct, by means of messages opposing a cease-fire, attacking High Court of Justice rulings, objecting to the supply of food to Gazans, criticizing the air force's restraint and deciding that there are no innocents in Gaza.

It is also indirect, with a range of comments that contravene the army's declared values: signs demanding the return to Gush Katif, religious ceremonies such as bringing in Torah scrolls and putting mezuzahs on Gazan houses, demonstrating enthusiasm over the destruction of homes (for example, a female soldier rejoicing in a destroyed children's room), ritual-religious damage to mosques, calls for revenge and reports of carrying it out, such as boasting by a reservist company commander, "Battalion 2908 has entered Beit Hanoun and done what Shimon and Levy did to Nablus."

We're not just talking about soldiers venting. Field commanders are cooperating and sending messages of vengeance, such as the order of the day by Division 36 commander Brig.-Gen. David Bar Kalifa ("He took revenge upon his adversaries" (Deuteronomy) or a battalion commander at Training Base 1, the officers' training base, who called not to repeat the mistake of King Saul, who was merciful to Amalek.

This reached a peak when 90 reservist battalion commanders petitioned the IDF chief of staff not to stop in Gaza, Lebanon, and the West Bank until victory. Such a public challenge by reservist officers about what they consider to be a restrained approach by the political echelon is unprecedented.

Nor is this mere rhetoric; it is reflected by conduct in the field. It is enough to say that the shooting of the three escaped hostages would not have happened were it not for the open-fire orders disregarding the law, when in practice every Gazan man is considered a legitimate target. And we are not yet talking about the violent conduct in the West Bank, which in practice seeks to ignite an armed uprising in that sector.

These actions should be considered an escalation in processes of the past 20 years, which are centered on challenges by the national-religious camp and an uprising by blue-collar soldiers (following the Elor Azaria affair) against the IDF's supposed restraint. This is an attempt to reshape the army into a pincer movement, an uprising from below backed by the right-wing leadership, and expressed, for example, by the actions taken against the IDF chief of staff when he dared suspend soldiers who desecrated a mosque in Jenin.

More worrying is the collapse of the army hierarchy. The chief of staff hears the calls for revenge, see the breaches of discipline, the disparaging attitude towards the open-fire rules, but he does almost nothing. The right-wing terror has fallen on him.

The army does not even hear the warnings sounded about these acts and their potential for lawsuits against Israel. It is only called out to stop the spreading looting, but is sufficed by a call by the IDF chief education officer in a statement that is not a clear command, and presents the looting as harmful to the army and not a breach of the moral command, "Thou shalt not steal."

It is possible that the IDF is leveraging the passions of the soldiers and their commanders to instill battle spirit, but after the war an effort will have to be made to rehabilitate the ground forces before some of them become gangs.

‹ NWOPC ALERT! ‘Operation Al-Aqsa Flood’ Day 142: UN experts call for immediate arms embargo on Israel – Mondoweiss
Index
U.S. prepping Israel for "multi-front war"; Toledo-area guard called up ›
Forward to a Friend
 
  • This mailing list is a public mailing list - anyone may join or leave, at any time.
  • This mailing list is a group discussion list (unmoderated)

  • Start a new thread, email: peacelist@nwopc.org

This mailing list is an attempt to replace the nwopc yahoo group mailing list. This is a discussion list to share thoughts, ideas and articles that might serve to promote peace in our communities and to end the cultures of war.

Privacy Policy:

NWOPC or any person working on this mail list will not share any data with anyone. We respect your privacy and take it very serious.

Monitoring of any participation or attempted participation in the Peace List by any governmental authority for any purpose whatsoever is strictly forbidden and will result in immediate exclusion and possible referral for prosecution or civil lawsuit.

Other list policies may be found by clicking here.