A few comments on Kaptur's form letter and superficial change of heart

 
From: "Terry Lodge tjlodge50@PROTECTED [Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition]" <peacelist@PROTECTED>
Date: February 12th 2024
   In some respects, those of you who have worked so very hard, turning out in force and with energy and sincerity to convince Congresswoman Kaptur to call for a ceasefire, you can take credit for giving Marcy food for thought. She's changed her positions.  Maybe.

   But first, look at the dates of the letters she has finally signed onto. She finally got around to signing on to a November 16, 2023 letter and a January 18, 2024 one today. I'd bet that her staff embedded her signature up high in the signature blocks to make it appear that she signed on contemporaneously to when those letters were sent, but we know better.

Also, the two state solution is as dead as 35000 Gazans, and if you read her guest editorial in the Blade, it's horrid, conflates the "terrorism" of Palestine with Russians and China, provides for little to no self-determination by the Palestinians and is hopelessly shallow as to her understanding of what lies beneath the genocide.

And still, Marcy has not called for a ceasefire, has no comprehension that Israel is destroying itself as a viable state and as a trustworthy partner for any purpose. Where are the half a trillion bucks gonna come from to let the Palestinians liveS in Gaza again, much less let them live in peace with the freedom to not be shot and harassed at the border?

 As with all Cold War twaddle, Marcy speaks as though terrorists just exist for the chance to destroy us because they hate our freedom. She demonstrates her ongoing ignorance of history, of genuine underlying issues, does not understand the tentacles of Empire and is safely ensconced within her American exceptionalism.

While Congresswoman Kaptur has superficially "changed" her position because she can see electoral disaster ahead, it comes at the end of literally months of people imploring her to act.  Had she taken these positions willingly, about, oh, 20,000 lives and 50,000 injuries a couple hundred billion dollars' worth of carpet bombing ago, it might have been sincere. This is protection against critical voters.

                  Terry


On Monday, February 12, 2024 at 11:53:12 PM EST, Anne Marie Abowd anneabowd@PROTECTED [Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition] <peacelist@PROTECTED> wrote:


 

From: anneabowd@PROTECTED

A hopeful response from Marcy Kaptur.  Now the President must demand an immediate ceasefire, and reparations to Gazans; and make sure that Jewish settlers will not be allowed in Gaza.  And all killing of innocent 
Gazans, will stop by the REAL TERRORISTS,  THE IDF AND THE SETTLERS. 
Biden must act immediately to assure Kaptur’s promises, and stop all aid to Israel NOW.  

Anne

Begin forwarded message:

From: "Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur" <OH09MK.Outreach@PROTECTED>
Subject: An Update On My Work Related To The Ongoing Situation In Gaza
Date: February 12, 2024 at 5:04:50 PM EST
To: anneabowd@PROTECTED

News from Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur

Image

February 12, 2024

Dear Thomas and Anne,

Thank you for your continued willingness to engage with me in dialogue about the terrible war taking place in Gaza. In continuation of our conversation, I wanted to share an update with you about the conflict and about my work to address the conflict and secure a durable and lasting peace. 

On February 1st, President Biden issued a new Executive Order to sanction Israeli settlers who for too long have been perpetrating violence and intimidating acts against Palestinians and their communities in the West Bank. In November, I signed a letter to Secretary of State Antony Blinken calling on the Administration to address this dangerous situation in the West Bank and to hold those responsible to account. You can read the full letter by clicking here. I am grateful for the President’s actions, which will work towards a more peaceful West Bank. 

Additionally, there were recent reports from Israel describing how Israeli Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir called for Jewish settlers to enter Gaza and establish permanent settlements there. This message conflicts with that of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who has stated Israel’s official policy is to not maintain a permanent presence in Gaza after the war. However, to have a Minister level official in Israel’s government make such a call is deeply concerning. 

That is why I helped lead a letter with 61 of my House colleagues that calls upon Secretary of State Antony Blinken and the Biden Administration to forcefully affirm to Israel America’s opposition to the forced and permanent displacement of Palestinians from their homes in Gaza. Already over 80 percent of Gazans have been displaced by the fighting that began on October 7th. Every Palestinian has the unreconcilable right to return to their home in Gaza and anyone who attempts to prevent their return must be held to account. You can review a full copy of this letter by clicking here. 

Lastly, I authored an opinion article discussing one of the pathways I believe could best secure a durable and lasting peace between Israel and an independent and sovereign Palestinian state. You can find my full op-ed in the Toledo Blade by clicking here. This is but one concept that I have shared, meanwhile intense negotiations continue between the parties in the conflict. For me and so many constituents who I have heard from, release of the hostages who have now been held for 127 days remains a top priority. 

Only through a genuine process of reconciliation, including the returning of land to its rightful Gazan owners, and an international effort to help rebuild Gaza, will peace be possible. We must take every step possible to achieve lasting peace in this region. I remain committed to that cause and am grateful for your engagement with my office about this critical and urgent issue.

Sincerely,

Image


Marcy Kaptur 
U.S. Representative

Unsubscribe  Privacy Policy


 

Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition

Post to: Northwest Ohio Peace Coalition ( peacelist@PROTECTED )
Manage Your Subscription
Unsubscribe
                                                           
Forward to a Friend
 
  • This mailing list is a public mailing list - anyone may join or leave, at any time.
  • This mailing list is a group discussion list (unmoderated)
  • Start a new thread, email: peacelist@nwopc.org

This mailing list is an attempt to replace the nwopc yahoo group mailing list. This is a discussion list to share thoughts, ideas and articles that might serve to promote peace in our communities and to end the cultures of war.

Privacy Policy:

NWOPC or any person working on this mail list will not share any data with anyone. We respect your privacy and take it very serious.

Monitoring of any participation or attempted participation in the Peace List by any governmental authority for any purpose whatsoever is strictly forbidden and will result in immediate exclusion and possible referral for prosecution or civil lawsuit.

Other list policies may be found by clicking here.